You may have heard card fees are coming down. A trade newsletter said so, or a rep mentioned it on a call. Then your November statement shows up, and the rate on it looks just like October's.
That's because nothing has changed yet. On Monday, November 16, Judge Brian Cogan held a 90-minute hearing in Brooklyn on the swipe-fee settlement between Visa, Mastercard and merchants. He ended it without a ruling and without a date for one, saying only that he’d decide as soon as possible. He also made clear what happens if he says no.
Two ways this can go
If he approves it, the deal’s terms would start to take effect, on a schedule set in the settlement agreement. Each network gets 90 days to rewrite its card-acceptance rules. The rate cut starts no earlier than four months after approval, timed to the networks’ April and October rate updates. Then expect an appeal. The National Association of Convenience Stores said in June it would take the deal to the 2nd Circuit if it got final approval. About 1,000 larger merchants and trade groups objected to it, led by Walmart, the National Retail Federation and the convenience store association.
If he rejects it, the case goes to trial in 2027. Cogan told the parties he won’t do “any more head-banging to get a settlement if I reject this settlement,” according to Payments Dive. He laid out about two months to prepare and a trial of roughly two months. If the merchants won, there would still be a fight over what the court should order the networks to do. This case has been running for 21 years. A different judge rejected an earlier settlement in June 2024.
Either way, the lower rates aren’t on your statement this year. Plan as if they won’t be.
What’s at stake for your store
We covered the full terms in our piece before the hearing. The short version: average credit card interchange down 10 basis points, or 0.10%, for five years. A 1.25% cap on interchange for standard consumer credit cards for at least eight years. The right to stop taking premium rewards or commercial cards. And new room to surcharge or offer discounts for cheaper ways to pay.
That cut is an average across each network, not a promise about your rate. On $500,000 a year in credit card sales, 0.10% comes to $500. Whether you’d see any of it depends on how your processor prices you — and that’s worth asking about now.
Where the case stands
The settlement covers every business that accepted Visa or Mastercard in the U.S. between December 18, 2020 and June 13, 2026, according to the court’s order, and no one can opt out. Cogan gave the deal preliminary approval in June. Whatever he decides can be appealed to the 2nd Circuit in New York.
What to plan on until he rules
- 01Budget 2027 at today’s card costs. Use your last 12 months of statements, not a rate someone expects. If the cut comes, treat it as found money.
- 02Don’t change your counter yet. No new signs about which cards you take, and no terminal changes. Even after an approval, the networks have 90 days to change their rules — and an appeal could still overturn the deal.
- 03If you surcharge now, keep following today’s rules. The settlement’s surcharge terms aren’t in force. Your state’s law and the current network rules still decide what you can charge, and those vary a lot by state.
- 04Get your card mix on paper. Ask your processor for last year’s card sales broken out by standard, premium and commercial cards. You’ll need that number to decide whether declining any of them is worth it, if you ever get the choice.
- 05Ask how a rate cut would reach you. If you pay one flat rate on every card, ask your processor in writing whether a network cut would lower what you pay.
Pull your last 12 months of statements this week and set next year’s card-cost line from those. Then whichever way the ruling goes, you’re not waiting on it to plan.
Joe Radest
1 Step Technologies — Peachtree City, GA. 25+ years in the payment industry, over $50M in volume a month.