1 Step Technologies
All articles
Cash flowNovember 13, 20264 min read

More states want to stop card fees on sales tax and tips: what it means for your 2027 costs

Joe Radest

Ring up a $2,000 sofa where the sales tax is 7%, and the card is charged $2,140. The card fee is figured on the whole amount, including the $140 you collect for the state and never keep. A restaurant pays the same way on the tip that goes straight to the server.

More states are trying to change that. The Electronic Transactions Association counted 32 interchange bills in 20 states, plus Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, this year alone, Payments Dive reported on November 10. Most of them go after the fee on tax and tips.

Where the bills stand

Illinois is the only state where one became law. Colorado’s legislature passed a tax-only version this year, and the governor vetoed it in June. The Illinois law is now set to take effect July 1, 2027, a year later than planned. A federal judge has already blocked it for national banks, federal credit unions, out-of-state banks and the card networks. That leaves a narrow slice of cards, mostly from banks and credit unions chartered in Illinois.

We walked through what’s left of the Illinois ban in September. The state has appealed, and Payments Dive reports the Seventh Circuit will hear arguments on January 27, 2027. Merchant groups have also sued the federal regulators behind those exemptions.

New Jersey has a Senate bill, S4360, and an Assembly version, A5014. The two read the same. They bar card networks from charging interchange on the sales tax or the tip. They also bar them from raising the rate on the rest of the sale to make up the difference. The law would start 180 days after it’s signed. Both bills are still in committee.

Pennsylvania’s House Bill 2090 covers sales tax only, not tips. It cleared the House Finance Committee on February 4 and hasn’t had a floor vote.

Massachusetts set its bill, S.688, aside for study on July 31.

Only one state has turned this into law, and that law is in court. Plan next year without it.

Why it isn’t in your 2027 budget yet

Count what has actually changed for a store outside Illinois — nothing. The New Jersey and Pennsylvania bills are stuck short of a floor vote. If New Jersey’s passes next year, it still wouldn’t start for another six months. And the banks have shown in Illinois that they will sue.

There’s also a catch in the bills themselves. Both Illinois’s law and New Jersey’s bill only remove the fee when the merchant sends the tax or tip amount along with the sale. If your system sends one total, you’d have to file the paperwork within 180 days to get the fee back.

Work out your number

Find last year’s sales tax collected on card sales, plus card tips. Then divide your total card fees by your card volume to get your real rate. Multiply the two. As an example only: $60,000 of tax and tips at a 2.5% rate is $1,500 a year. That’s what these bills are worth to you, at most.

What to do now

  1. 01Work out your number. Use the box above. If it’s a few hundred dollars, this isn’t worth your time. If it’s a few thousand, keep reading.
  2. 02Ask what your terminal sends. Does it pass the tax as its own field, or one total? Does it send the tip separately, including tips added after the card is run? That’s what decides whether any of these laws would help you.
  3. 03Budget 2027 as if nothing changes. If a law passes in your state, treat the savings as a bonus, not a plan. Surcharging rules already differ by state, and this would be one more.
  4. 04Know who’s pushing it. In both states, trade groups are behind these bills. The New Jersey Restaurant & Hospitality Association is working with lawmakers on New Jersey’s, and the Pennsylvania Food Merchants Association backs Pennsylvania’s. If you want a say, start there.

One question before you set next year’s budget

Ask whoever runs your payments one thing: does our system send the tax and the tip as separate amounts, or just the total? If you can’t get a straight answer, talk to an expert at 770-766-1060.

Written by

Joe Radest

1 Step Technologies — Peachtree City, GA. 25+ years in the payment industry, over $50M in volume a month.

Stop losing money in the cracks

Want to see what this looks like on your business?

Talk to a person in Peachtree City who knows your industry — no offshore queue, no ticket number. We'll look at how you take payments today and where the leaks are.

GET STARTED TODAY

Ready to streamline your business?

Our team of payments and technology specialists are here to discuss next steps and answer any questions you may have.

Prefer to talk? 770-766-1060 · info@1steptech.com1 Step Technologies is a registered ISO/MSP of Fifth Third Bank, N.A., Cincinnati, OH.