Every card sale you run carries a fee on the full total. That includes the sales tax you pass to the state and the tip you pass to your server. Illinois passed a law to stop that. Then two federal regulators stepped in, and most of it was blocked.
On November 12, the merchants hit back. Nine trade groups filed two lawsuits in federal court in Washington, D.C., one against the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and one against the National Credit Union Administration. Those are the two agencies whose rules exempted most banks and credit unions from the Illinois law.
What the merchants filed
The groups include the National Retail Federation, the National Grocers Association, the Illinois Restaurant Association and the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, according to the NRF’s announcement.
The complaint against the OCC makes two main arguments. First, the agency issued its rule and its order in April without the public notice and comment that federal law requires. Second, the law that governs national banks doesn’t cover fees that the card networks set, not the banks, so it gives the OCC no power to override Illinois. It asks the court to declare both actions unlawful and throw them out.
The complaint against the NCUA makes the same case about the credit union rule the agency issued in June.
Illinois merchants pay upwards of $242 million a year in card fees on taxes and tips alone, according to an Illinois Fuel & Retail Association estimate cited in the OCC complaint.
Why this case matters more than the last one
The fee ban had held up in court. In February, Judge Virginia Kendall ruled that federal banking law didn’t override it. Then the OCC issued its rule and order, the appeals court sent the case back, and in June she blocked the fee ban for national banks, federal savings associations, out-of-state state banks and the card networks. In September she added federal credit unions.
But she didn’t sound convinced. As quoted in the merchants’ complaint, she wrote that she did “not find the underlying justifications present in the Interim Final Order to be particularly persuasive.” She said she was “not in a posture to invalidate” it, because nobody in that case had challenged the order itself under the law that governs how agencies make rules.
These two lawsuits are that challenge.
The judge who blocked the Illinois law said the regulator’s reasoning didn’t persuade her. These suits are the case she said she couldn’t rule on.
If the merchants win, the main reason most banks and credit unions are exempt goes away. If they lose, the OCC’s rule stands. The complaint warns that the OCC’s actions “cast significant doubt on the ability of states like Illinois to pass legislation” of this kind. That matters if your state is weighing a bill of its own.
How long this takes
This won’t be quick — federal agencies get 60 days to answer a lawsuit, counted from when the U.S. attorney is served. Meanwhile, the Illinois attorney general appealed the September injunction on October 9, and Payments Dive reports the Seventh Circuit will hear arguments in late January. The Illinois law is set to start July 1, 2027.
Are you already in this fight?
If you belong to the Illinois Restaurant Association, the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, the National Grocers Association or the NRF, your group is one of the ones suing. Ask them what they need from members, such as your own numbers on fees paid on tax and tips.
What to do now
- 01Budget 2027 without it. Two courts are now involved, and neither has a deadline. If the ban survives, treat the savings as a bonus.
- 02Know your number. Add up last year’s sales tax and tips on card sales and multiply by your real card rate. We walked through how to work it out last week.
- 03Check what your terminal sends. The Illinois law only removes the fee when your system sends the tax and tip amounts with the sale. If it sends one total, you’d have to file paperwork to get the fee back.
The one thing to do this week
Ask whoever runs your payments whether your system sends the tax and the tip as separate amounts. It’s the same question whichever way the courts go. If you can’t get a straight answer, talk to an expert at 770-766-1060.
Joe Radest
1 Step Technologies — Peachtree City, GA. 25+ years in the payment industry, over $50M in volume a month.